Portland is a PR machine for light rail & streetcar
Here are Some Facts About Portland Oregon
“It must always be remembered how cost-effectiveness works in the public sector: the cost IS the benefit.” - author unknown
West Side Light Rail Time & Budget
Sources for above chart - all quoted text below is from the actual article |
||
Data used in chart above is in bold |
Date / Link to article |
This column contains mostly cut & pasted text from news sources linked in the date column. (search terms were: westside "light rail" OR MAX million) |
$295-$395 Million Riders: 34,150 |
The alignment, which was estimated to cost $195.4 million The expense of building the line from downtown Portland to that point is expected to run $100 million to $200 million more. He envisioned a daily ridership of 34,150 on the route in the year 2005, |
|
Open in 1997 |
"The line to Southwest 185th Avenue is scheduled to open in the fall of 1997, with the Hillsboro extension completed a year later." |
|
$963 million |
Hillsboro/City Center; * Opened: Sept. 12, 1998 * Length: 18 miles * Stations: 32 * Construction: July 1993-Sept. 1998 * Cost: $963 million |
|
24,000 riders |
This number comes this graphic (divided by 365) from the trimet publication, railfactsheet-westside.pdf, found on their web site in January 2007 . The graphic has since been removed from later versions of this publication. Also, a July 13, 1999 Oregonian article reported: "westside line has drawn an average of nearly 23,000 weekday riders since its opening" |
|
1988 Forecast |
2004 Actual |
Difference |
Ridership |
34,150 (for 2005) |
24,000 |
|
cost of MAX |
$295-395 million |
$963 million |
144-226% over budget (or 109-172% based on later estimates) |
opening date |
1997 |
1998 |
1 years late |
Table created from data found in Oregonian December 15, 1988, July 7, 1992 , July 13, 1999 (see below), the Trimet publication, Westside MAX Blue Line; |
|||
A Trimet FactSheet claims that:: The 18-mile Westside MAX extension, built on time and on budget, began service in 1998 between downtown Portland and the western suburbs of Beaverton and Hillsboro.Construction: July 1993-Sept. 1998; Funding: $963 million; Federal 73%; State/Local 27% |
|||
On October 29, 1998, the Oregonian reported that a TRI-MET COUNT SHOWS WESTSIDE ATTRACTS 1,773 NEW RIDERS . At its final cost of $963,000,000, that is $543,147 for each new rider ($963,000,000 / 1773 = $543,147) A look at the numbers shows that most of the riders were former bus riders. |
Here is what pages 23-26 of the Federal Transit Administration’s “Contractor Performance, Assessment Report”, September 2007 has to say:
(Charts reformatted to show just the Portland entry
Trimet’s trick is to use an optimistic projection to sell the project, then come out with a realistic one much later which is more accurate.
Bribery |
Cheaper & Better Transit |
EuroTranistShareLoss |
Elderly Travel |
GM & The Streetcar |
Commute Time Chart |
Top 10 Bus |
Clackamas Public Safety |
transit_congestion |
McLoughlin Plan |
CRC_Planning |
Zoneing Increases Cost, Hurts Economy |
High Rise |